VAR Admits Error: Haaland Goal Should Have Been Disallowed in Derby
Pro Ref confirmed VAR Matt Donohue erred in letting Haaland's goal stand in the Manchester Derby. The semi-automated system incorrectly ruled Haaland onside, overturning the offside flag.
TL;DR Pro Ref has officially confirmed that VAR Matt Donohue made a mistake by allowing Erling Haaland's goal to stand in Manchester City's 1-0 victory over Manchester United, despite Enzo Fernández being offside.
Key Points - Pro Ref confirmed the VAR error in the Manchester Derby. - The semi-automated system incorrectly overruled the assistant referee's offside flag. - The goal was the winner in City's 1-0 win. - Referees are generally performing well this season despite this incident.
What We Know According to The Guardian, Pro Ref stated that Donohue erred when the semi-automated system showed Haaland was onside. This decision overturned the assistant referee's flag, which had correctly identified Enzo Fernández in an offside position. The article notes that while this was a disappointing outcome for the specific decision, the officiating group has started the season well overall.
Why It Matters This incident highlights the potential limitations of semi-automated offside technology in high-stakes matches. It raises questions about the reliability of automated systems when they conflict with human on-field judgments in decisive moments of major derbies.
What Happens Next Speculation suggests the Premier League may review the calibration of the semi-automated offside system to prevent similar errors in future matches, though no official change in protocol has been announced.
Related News
Keep reading about related topics and teams.
Ronay: Tuchel Not Blamed for World Cup Exit as System Failure Cited
Barney Ronay argues England's World Cup failure stems from systemic issues, not Thomas Tuchel. The piece highlights Euro 2028 home advantage as a key opportunity for redemption.
Anthony Gordon Admits 'Surprise' at Tuchel's Argentina Semi-Final Choices
Anthony Gordon expresses surprise at Thomas Tuchel's decisions following England's World Cup semi-final loss to Argentina. The squad has regrouped to discuss the outcome.
Gordon Backs Tuchel: 'Possession Isn't in Our DNA'
Anthony Gordon defends Thomas Tuchel's tactical approach during the World Cup. The Barcelona winger admits England cannot replicate Spain's style of play.
Joe Hart Bemoans Lisandro Martinez's 'Uncomfortable' Fulham Own Goal
Joe Hart criticized the 'uncomfortable' own goal by Manchester United's Lisandro Martinez during their 1-1 draw with Fulham.