VAR Admits Error: Haaland Goal Should Have Been Disallowed in Derby
Pro Ref confirmed VAR Matt Donohue erred in letting Haaland's goal stand in the Manchester Derby. The semi-automated system incorrectly ruled Haaland onside, overturning the offside flag.
TL;DR Pro Ref has officially confirmed that VAR Matt Donohue made a mistake by allowing Erling Haaland's goal to stand in Manchester City's 1-0 victory over Manchester United, despite Enzo Fernández being offside.
Key Points - Pro Ref confirmed the VAR error in the Manchester Derby. - The semi-automated system incorrectly overruled the assistant referee's offside flag. - The goal was the winner in City's 1-0 win. - Referees are generally performing well this season despite this incident.
What We Know According to The Guardian, Pro Ref stated that Donohue erred when the semi-automated system showed Haaland was onside. This decision overturned the assistant referee's flag, which had correctly identified Enzo Fernández in an offside position. The article notes that while this was a disappointing outcome for the specific decision, the officiating group has started the season well overall.
Why It Matters This incident highlights the potential limitations of semi-automated offside technology in high-stakes matches. It raises questions about the reliability of automated systems when they conflict with human on-field judgments in decisive moments of major derbies.
What Happens Next Speculation suggests the Premier League may review the calibration of the semi-automated offside system to prevent similar errors in future matches, though no official change in protocol has been announced.
Related News
Keep reading about related topics and teams.
Ronaldinho Returns to Pro Football at 46: 'Is This My Last One?'
Ronaldinho made his 11-year comeback for Serie C's Ravenna at age 46. The Brazil legend played 45 minutes in a local derby, questioning if it was his final match.
Harviken Strikes as Villa End Five-Year WSL Derby Drought vs Birmingham
Mathilde Harviken scored the only goal to lead Aston Villa past Birmingham City. It was the first WSL derby between the two sides since May 2022.
EFC Global Expansion Plan Looms to Upend Fifa's Dominant Position
The European Football Clubs will release findings from a feasibility study on global expansion. The study could redefine football's governance landscape and shift power from Fifa to Europe's wealthiest clubs.
Red Bulls vs América 'Friendly' Ends in Mass Brawl and Six Red Cards
A chaotic friendly between the New York Red Bulls and Club América devolved into a mass brawl, resulting in six red cards and objects thrown from the stands.